pizza restaurant
Closed Now
Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Amenia (4957 NY-22, NY 12501)
About:
Family restaurant that prides itself on serving award winning pizzas and salads
Four Brothers Pizza Inn is located in Amenia (New York state) on the street of 4957 NY-22. If you want to ask about something we recommend contacting this place by phone. The Phone number is +18453738178. You can get more information from their website: https://fourbrothersrestaurants.com/. The coordinates that you can use in navigation applications to get to find Four Brothers Pizza Inn quickly are 41.849822, -73.557710. Scroll down to find out opening hours, reviews and other important information about Four Brothers Pizza Inn.
Have you noticed incorrect information? Contact us and send us the details!
Show menuAvailable amenities
Crowd
- Family friendly
- Groups
- Tourists
Payments
- Debit cards
Planning
- amenities.planning.accepts_reservations
Amenities
- Bar on site
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Toilets
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Kids' menu
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Vegetarian
- Wine
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- amenities.dining_options.has_catering
- Dessert
- Seats
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Kerbside pickup
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Health and safety
- Staff wear masks
- Staff get temperature checks
- Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Unavailable amenities
Service options
- Delivery
Categories
Tags
FAQ
Are the opening hours of Four Brothers Pizza Inn up to date?
Is the place part of a chain store?
Four Brothers Pizza Inn is my place. Can I manage it?
What categories is Four Brothers Pizza Inn listed in?
How is Four Brothers Pizza Inn rated?
What is the address of Four Brothers Pizza Inn?
How to Get in Touch With Four Brothers Pizza Inn?
Matt
July 19, 2022 visit. The meal was good and everyone was friendly but our server was working the outdoor patio in addition to the inside so there were things missed, like our initial drinks, the regular “how’s things” checkup, and a check that we had to get up and ask for after waiting well over 20 minutes. It’s a new world after COVID and staff is short everywhere. Management/owner should of picked up on their staff being overwhelmed and being pulled in multiple directions and stepped up to assist.
08.2022Matt
July 19, 2022 visit. The meal was good and everyone was friendly but our server was working the outdoor patio in addition to the inside so there were things missed, like our initial drinks, the regular “how’s things” checkup, and a check that we had to get up and ask for after waiting well over 20 minutes. It’s a new world after COVID and staff is short everywhere. Management/owner should of picked up on their staff being overwhelmed and being pulled in multiple directions and stepped up to assist.
08.2022Rich
Had a great experience and loved their Lobster Roll !! The "Drive In" area is great for little ones. Very family friendly...you can even rent out one of their Airstreams for the night !!
07.2022Rich
Had a great experience and loved their Lobster Roll !! The "Drive In" area is great for little ones. Very family friendly...you can even rent out one of their Airstreams for the night !!
07.2022Kerri
Disappointing. Calamari was fishy & chewy, the wings were mushy and the bbq sauce was way too sweet. Pizza was resemblant of Pizza Hut. Greek salad was ok. The frozen margaritas (which didn't come til after our food was on the table) were $15 each ........ The whole meal was WAY too expensive for the less-than-medicore food that's served here. Not a fan, won't be back .....
07.2022Kerri
Disappointing. Calamari was fishy & chewy, the wings were mushy and the bbq sauce was way too sweet. Pizza was resemblant of Pizza Hut. Greek salad was ok. The frozen margaritas (which didn't come til after our food was on the table) were $15 each ........ The whole meal was WAY too expensive for the less-than-medicore food that's served here. Not a fan, won't be back .....
07.2022Leor
The food is really great, we ate at Four Brothers two days in a row. This location has an awesome atmosphere especially for kids with an outdoor seating area, movie theater and kiddie rides. The staff is really great and helped me out after leaving something there -- they went above and beyond to keep it safe and have it returned. Thanks Tom and John and the entire staff!
07.2022Bob
Been going to Four Brothers since opening over 40 years ago. Never had anything other than great meals. Food is top quality, best pizza & Greek salad anywhere & super friendly staff. Billy runs a superb restaurant. Worth the trip.
07.2022Leor
The food is really great, we ate at Four Brothers two days in a row. This location has an awesome atmosphere especially for kids with an outdoor seating area, movie theater and kiddie rides. The staff is really great and helped me out after leaving something there -- they went above and beyond to keep it safe and have it returned. Thanks Tom and John and the entire staff!
07.2022Bob
Been going to Four Brothers since opening over 40 years ago. Never had anything other than great meals. Food is top quality, best pizza & Greek salad anywhere & super friendly staff. Billy runs a superb restaurant. Worth the trip.
07.2022Jacqueline
Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients. The lasagna was satisfying and tasty. Didn’t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhat thick. Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff.
06.2022Jacqueline
Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients. The lasagna was satisfying and tasty. Didn’t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhat thick. Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff.
06.2022amanda
First off I want to say they serve the appropriate amount of salad dressing for you to add to your salad. I didn’t have to ask for extra and I added as much as I wanted. The dressing was good, similar to Olive Garden, as was the salad itself. The came out quickly. It was good, better than expected, being at a movie theater, but not a place I would go to unless I was seeing a movie. I had the spanakopita, my boyfriend had the chicken gyro. We also had mozzarella sticks which were really good. I’d be tempted to get two orders to go to nom on while watching the movie.
06.2022amanda
First off I want to say they serve the appropriate amount of salad dressing for you to add to your salad. I didn’t have to ask for extra and I added as much as I wanted. The dressing was good, similar to Olive Garden, as was the salad itself. The came out quickly. It was good, better than expected, being at a movie theater, but not a place I would go to unless I was seeing a movie. I had the spanakopita, my boyfriend had the chicken gyro. We also had mozzarella sticks which were really good. I’d be tempted to get two orders to go to nom on while watching the movie.
06.2022Brandon
Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing “bad”. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texture wise. Quick and easy but not worth price.
08.2021Brandon
Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing “bad”. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texture wise. Quick and easy but not worth price.
08.2021Thomas
The place is cute. Has a good atmosphere and lots to do. Food is okay, service is good. However, $75 for burgers and shakes for four people is legitimately insane. There are several high class restaurants within a few minutes of this place that you can enjoy a five star meal for that price. If you’re okay with paying 75 bucks for fast food then you will enjoy the experience.
08.2021Thomas
The place is cute. Has a good atmosphere and lots to do. Food is okay, service is good. However, $75 for burgers and shakes for four people is legitimately insane. There are several high class restaurants within a few minutes of this place that you can enjoy a five star meal for that price. If you’re okay with paying 75 bucks for fast food then you will enjoy the experience.
08.2021Carmen
Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I should've of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.
08.2020Carmen
Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I should've of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.
08.2020