Best cookie shop in Nantucket, Massachusetts (MA) 2024

2021:When you are looking for a homemade sweet treat this is the place to go! This store is very reasonably priced. I purchased a vanilla cupcake and it was amazing.The cupcake convinced me to special order a birthday cake. I showed the baker the design I wanted with roses, what colors I wanted the roses to be, and when to have it ready by for pick up and she executed it beautifully and in a timely manner! I love it and my family loved it. The staff is very friendly, welcoming and patient. I also got an order of donuts for my family and they were amazing and everyone loved them! The cake taste amazing too! 2022:came back again and ordered a cake. I tried the chocolate cake this year. I’m speechless and my tastebuds are in ecstasy! Best chocolate cake ever! The colors they did for me are perfect. I wanted the cake to match my nautical dish set I was using for my birthday and the staff did the perfect coral and peach toned flowers on the chocolate cake to match! Thank you soooo much for making my Birthday! ~nancy