Best italian restaurant in Haddonfield, New Jersey (NJ) 2024

When everyone is downsizing portions and increasing prices, Nocellos’ is delivering huge sandwiches at reasonable prices. This is the half of my pork sandwich I could not finish. Seeded rolls, sweet pork with spicy long hots — DELICIOUS! All their sandwiches are amazing, I’ve tried them all. Joe takes care of his customers. Go to Nocellos, guarantee you’ll be satisfied. ~C

italian restaurant pizza restaurant

We’ve been here twice and each time has been better than the last. It takes us over about hour and a half to get to Valente’s and it doesn’t even matter because it’s that good. To give you portion context, there were three of us and we ordered all but two menu items and shared them. I would suggest ordering everything you want and having it boxed up if you don’t finish it because you won’t want to miss out on an item! This happened to us the first time where we got one item from the Overture and one item from the Aria and wished we’d ordered more. This time we did not make that mistake and it was well worth it! The service was a little bit slow but honestly it was really busy for a Saturday night and the food more than makes up for it. Also, make sure to bring your own wine. Incredible food and we love this place and will be back! ~Pat

italian restaurant fine dining restaurant small plates restaurant southern italian restaurant