Best italian restaurant in Seaside Park, New Jersey (NJ) 2024

I was in Seaside Heights for business and decided to try The Sawmill as it appeared to be a quiet, somewhat fancy sports bar by the pictures shared on Google. Sports bar, yes; quiet, not at all. Fancy? Not really. This is a family restaurant and I learned it's famous for really big slices of pizza. I had a turkey burger and salad and the food was fine but not something I would go out of my way to eat. The restaurant was packed and the staff were working hard, so while I'm sure this is a great place for a snack or quick slice, I don't think it would be a destination for fine dining. There is a large bar and plenty of TVs to watch sporting events and you can access the boardwalk directly from the restaurant. ~Colin

Oh my gif best pizza I have ever eaten! Ordered grandma’s pizza extra crispy. Absolutely delicious. No more traveling to NY City to get my pizza itch scratched. Micheal you are amazing!!! ~Rebecca