Best italian restaurant in Middle Grove, New York (NY) 2024

First timer for dinner. Needed a reservation, place gets busy. The wait for food to arrive wasn't bad at all. Nice rustic atmosphere. The wait staff was friendly. Place was clean. Known for their pizza we all opted for a dinner plate instead. Saw pizza's going by all night and now wish I had tried that. Warm bread came out first and that was really good. We had the fried calamari appetizer and it was god, but not great. They over breaded it. I tried the cheese ravioli and added a side of meatballs. The sauce was good. The ravioli was really good but the meatballs were barely okay. It was like they didn't season them at all. Still, overall I give this place a 3.5 out of 5 which is good. I think we'll head back to try a pizza and see where they land. Hoping to upgrade them to a 4 star. ~Joe