Best supermarket in Monsey, New York (NY) 2025

I love this store even more now that it is surrounded by mega-markets. Wesley has long been my go-to place for fresh and prepared meats, a wide variety of sides, high quality produce, delicious baked goods from both in-house and outside sources, and everything else a kosher market can have. The difference is that I do not have to battle the crowds or waste time wandering through the incredibly long aisles at the other, more colorfully named stores only to have to hike back when I realize I forgot something. And their prices are realistic and consistent, unlike a certain newer chain that roped me in years ago with low prices and then shot them through the roof. For quality, service, and convenience, I am staying loyal to Wesley Kosher. ~Susan

Much more complete assortment than you might expect from looking at this supermarket from the outside. ~Ely

2 years ago I would definitely give a 5 star. Reason being is that they raised their prices on fruits and vegetables with 70% across the board For example parsnip $3.49 elsewhere 1.99 turnip 1.99 elsewhere. 99... im not sure why think they are whole foods?? Definitely not a community grocery experience.. try shopping at Rockland kosher much better prices on everyday healthy item's.. maybe on chocolate and junk they are more expensive. But you can survive without it Check it out your self you'll be shocked... ~kool