Best italian restaurant in Youngstown, Ohio (OH) 2025

In our listing you'll find the best places from the italian restaurant category in Youngstown, Ohio. Some of the most popular zip codes in Youngstown, OH for italian restaurant include 44505, 44515.
We found 2 places.

Jimmy's Italian Specialties

What a wonderful place just happened to be Youngstown area this town is full of beautiful historical architecture but this food and bakery 😋 is worth the drive and effort to get to. I tried multiple things and they were all great. Love all the seating area and patio... what wonderful ambience. A+ ~Celina

deli bakery cake shop gift basket store italian restaurant pastry shop pizzatakeaway sandwich shop wedding bakery wine store

3230 Belmont Ave , Youngstown, OH 44505

Belleria Pizza & Italian

I LOVE Belleria’s Pizza !!! I haven’t had one since the ‘90’s, and I finally drove over 200 miles to get a Pizza & an Italian Sub… and they were both everything that I remembered. Absolutely OUTSTANDING !!! There is something uniquely special about Northeast Ohio Pizza !!! Ya, it’s a thing… ~Tool

pizzatakeaway italian restaurant

5625 Mahoning Ave , Youngstown, OH 44515

FAQ italian restaurant in Youngstown, OH

What are the zip codes in the city of Youngstown?

City Youngstown has such zip codes as: 44505, 44515.

What are the highly rated italian restaurant in Youngstown, OH?

The best-rated places in category italian restaurant in city Youngstown are:

Jimmy's Italian Specialties (3230 Belmont Ave) - 4.9/5 stars
Belleria Pizza & Italian (5625 Mahoning Ave) - 3.4/5 stars