Best pizza delivery service in New Glarus, Wisconsin (WI) 2024

In our listing you'll find the best places from the pizza delivery service category in New Glarus, Wisconsin. Some of the most popular zip codes in New Glarus, WI for pizza delivery service include 53574.
We found 1 place.

Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus

If you like expensive drinks and overpriced pizza then this is the place for you!! The service was lackluster, we didn't receive any drinks once our food came and were never checked in with. The appetizer we bought (pretzel bites) was good except that they brought us a spicy mustard dipping sauce instead of the beer cheese that was suppose to accompany it. If we had proper service we could've corrected this issue... The pizza arrived in a decent time and had plenty of toppings, however, the crust was not cooked all the way, the cheese was not melted in the middle, the toppings all fell off because they were on top of the cheese and the sauce was minimal at best. We asked for suggestions for a drink that was apple ale based and the server suggested a Fandango... It was $10 a can, was sour cherry flavored and tasted like wine. While he did offer to get us another drink I opted for soda instead. ~Donna

(10 reviews)
pizza restaurant italian restaurant pizza delivery service

FAQ pizza delivery service in New Glarus, WI

What are the zip codes in the city of New Glarus?

City New Glarus has such zip codes as: 53574.

What are the highly rated pizza delivery service in New Glarus, WI?

The best-rated places in category pizza delivery service in city New Glarus are: