pizza restaurant
Closed Now
Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Pleasant Valley (1890 US-44, NY 12569)
About:
family friendly restaurant known for delicious pizzas and salads.
Four Brothers Pizza Inn is located in Pleasant Valley (New York state) on the street of 1890 US-44. If you want to ask about something we recommend contacting this place by phone. The Phone number is +18456353777. You can get more information from their website: https://fourbrothersrestaurants.com/. The coordinates that you can use in navigation applications to get to find Four Brothers Pizza Inn quickly are 41.751872, -73.798883. Scroll down to find out opening hours, reviews and other important information about Four Brothers Pizza Inn.
Have you noticed incorrect information? Contact us and send us the details!
Show menuAvailable amenities
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
Planning
- amenities.planning.accepts_reservations
Amenities
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Toilets
Offerings
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Kids' menu
- Quick bite
- Small plates
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Kerbside pickup
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Health and safety
- Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Unavailable amenities
Four Brothers Pizza Inn doesn't have any unavailable amenities.Categories
Tags
FAQ
Are the opening hours of Four Brothers Pizza Inn up to date?
Is the place part of a chain store?
Four Brothers Pizza Inn is my place. Can I manage it?
What categories is Four Brothers Pizza Inn listed in?
How is Four Brothers Pizza Inn rated?
What is the address of Four Brothers Pizza Inn?
How to Get in Touch With Four Brothers Pizza Inn?
Vincent
Stick to the pizza and forget the rest of the menu. I hear the pizza is good although I've never tried it; there certainly were plenty of people eating it in the restaurant and picking it up to go. As far as my dining experience went it was pretty bad. I ordered lasagna which came in a casserole dish and just barely resembled lasagna. Instead of layers of pasta with ricotta cheese and sauce, this was essentially lasagna pasta in almost a tomato like soup with a big melted chunk of mozzarella on top. My friend ordered salmon which came with mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. Unfortunately the water from the vegetables was all over the plate drowning/ruining the mashed potatoes. The salmon wasn't very good nor were the vegetables. The bread that came with the meal was also dry and stale tasting. As I said earlier, just order pizza and you'll probably be ok. Whatever you do don't order anything else or you'll probably be very sorry you decided to eat that night. I definitely do not recommend the Pleasant Valley location. I have eaten at Four Brothers in Amenia a few years back and had baked ziti and it was pretty good. Not sure if there was a change or just a difference between locations.
08.2022Vincent
Stick to the pizza and forget the rest of the menu. I hear the pizza is good although I've never tried it; there certainly were plenty of people eating it in the restaurant and picking it up to go. As far as my dining experience went it was pretty bad. I ordered lasagna which came in a casserole dish and just barely resembled lasagna. Instead of layers of pasta with ricotta cheese and sauce, this was essentially lasagna pasta in almost a tomato like soup with a big melted chunk of mozzarella on top. My friend ordered salmon which came with mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. Unfortunately the water from the vegetables was all over the plate drowning/ruining the mashed potatoes. The salmon wasn't very good nor were the vegetables. The bread that came with the meal was also dry and stale tasting. As I said earlier, just order pizza and you'll probably be ok. Whatever you do don't order anything else or you'll probably be very sorry you decided to eat that night. I definitely do not recommend the Pleasant Valley location. I have eaten at Four Brothers in Amenia a few years back and had baked ziti and it was pretty good. Not sure if there was a change or just a difference between locations.
08.2022Vincent
Stick to the pizza and forget the rest of the menu. I hear the pizza is good although I've never tried it; there certainly were plenty of people eating it in the restaurant and picking it up to go. As far as my dining experience went it was pretty bad. I ordered lasagna which came in a casserole dish and just barely resembled lasagna. Instead of layers of pasta with ricotta cheese and sauce, this was essentially lasagna pasta in almost a tomato like soup with a big melted chunk of mozzarella on top. My friend ordered salmon which came with mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. Unfortunately the water from the vegetables was all over the plate drowning/ruining the mashed potatoes. The salmon wasn't very good nor were the vegetables. The bread that came with the meal was also dry and stale tasting. As I said earlier, just order pizza and you'll probably be ok. Whatever you do don't order anything else or you'll probably be very sorry you decided to eat that night. I definitely do not recommend the Pleasant Valley location. I have eaten at Four Brothers in Amenia a few years back and had baked ziti and it was pretty good. Not sure if there was a change or just a difference between locations.
08.2022happiness
One of the best pizza i ever had… the brothers pizza pie is the best pizza in new york.. very clean & modern decor…
07.2022Kenneth
Have been coming here for upwards of 30 years, my family use to have a house by Hunns Lake and my fondest memories were always stopping at Four Brothers and sitting in a booth and eating their amazing pizza! Time has passed and that house is gone, I now live in Brooklyn but every opportunity that I get to return(hikes, fair, wedding) upstate I stop here for one of the best pizza's I’ve ever had(and trust me I’ve eaten a lot). Highly recommend
07.2022Matthew
First time there was in 1980, and boy have the Four Brothers aged well! Pizza and Greek salad better than I remembered and the interior decor made for a nice and pleasant dining experience. Thank you, Four Brothers, for remaining consistently good, and for being a high light of my Pleasant Valley reunion.
07.2022Josh
Nostalgia reigns supreme at this pizza place. Their pizzas are reminiscent of the best that sit-down pizza parlors had to offer 30, 40 years ago. Share a pie and a Greek salad with friends and family.
07.2022happiness
One of the best pizza i ever had… the brothers pizza pie is the best pizza in new york.. very clean & modern decor…
07.2022Kenneth
Have been coming here for upwards of 30 years, my family use to have a house by Hunns Lake and my fondest memories were always stopping at Four Brothers and sitting in a booth and eating their amazing pizza! Time has passed and that house is gone, I now live in Brooklyn but every opportunity that I get to return(hikes, fair, wedding) upstate I stop here for one of the best pizza's I’ve ever had(and trust me I’ve eaten a lot). Highly recommend
07.2022Matthew
First time there was in 1980, and boy have the Four Brothers aged well! Pizza and Greek salad better than I remembered and the interior decor made for a nice and pleasant dining experience. Thank you, Four Brothers, for remaining consistently good, and for being a high light of my Pleasant Valley reunion.
07.2022Josh
Nostalgia reigns supreme at this pizza place. Their pizzas are reminiscent of the best that sit-down pizza parlors had to offer 30, 40 years ago. Share a pie and a Greek salad with friends and family.
07.2022happiness
One of the best pizza i ever had… the brothers pizza pie is the best pizza in new york.. very clean & modern decor…
07.2022Kenneth
Have been coming here for upwards of 30 years, my family use to have a house by Hunns Lake and my fondest memories were always stopping at Four Brothers and sitting in a booth and eating their amazing pizza! Time has passed and that house is gone, I now live in Brooklyn but every opportunity that I get to return(hikes, fair, wedding) upstate I stop here for one of the best pizza's I’ve ever had(and trust me I’ve eaten a lot). Highly recommend
07.2022Matthew
First time there was in 1980, and boy have the Four Brothers aged well! Pizza and Greek salad better than I remembered and the interior decor made for a nice and pleasant dining experience. Thank you, Four Brothers, for remaining consistently good, and for being a high light of my Pleasant Valley reunion.
07.2022Josh
Nostalgia reigns supreme at this pizza place. Their pizzas are reminiscent of the best that sit-down pizza parlors had to offer 30, 40 years ago. Share a pie and a Greek salad with friends and family.
07.2022chandra
Had a wonderful lunch today with my family outside on the terrace. The Greek salad was delicious and really fresh! We had garlic bread which is the best around followed by a large pizza and baked ziti. I like their variety of fresh toppings and their baked ziti had a nice amount of cheese on top.. it was really an enjoyable experience and the staff is very friendly. I highly recommend any of their locations. Thank you for making my day a pleasant one !
06.2022chandra
Had a wonderful lunch today with my family outside on the terrace. The Greek salad was delicious and really fresh! We had garlic bread which is the best around followed by a large pizza and baked ziti. I like their variety of fresh toppings and their baked ziti had a nice amount of cheese on top.. it was really an enjoyable experience and the staff is very friendly. I highly recommend any of their locations. Thank you for making my day a pleasant one !
06.2022chandra
Had a wonderful lunch today with my family outside on the terrace. The Greek salad was delicious and really fresh! We had garlic bread which is the best around followed by a large pizza and baked ziti. I like their variety of fresh toppings and their baked ziti had a nice amount of cheese on top.. it was really an enjoyable experience and the staff is very friendly. I highly recommend any of their locations. Thank you for making my day a pleasant one !
06.2022Gloria
Stopped here during our visit. Ordered the “brothers pizza” with two dinner sized salads. The house greek dressed is SO DELICIOUS!!! And the pizza was the most comforting pizza we’ve had. Reminded us of home. Good amount of cheese and toppings. Service was perfect. Will definitely be back on our next visit. A medium is definitely good for 3-4 to share.
08.2021Nathaniel
OMG!!! THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!! Ok let me breath. ☺️, on my lunch break my coworker and I picked this place at random. I’m soooooo glad we did. I ordered the Calamari and the Philly Grinder with the SOTD. It didn’t take long and the small time we waited was worth it. Everything is so fresh. The one waitress was quick, accurate and friendly. Lastly the price was reasonable and worth every penny. Simply put, do yourself a favor and stop by here. NOW!!
08.2021Gloria
Stopped here during our visit. Ordered the “brothers pizza” with two dinner sized salads. The house greek dressed is SO DELICIOUS!!! And the pizza was the most comforting pizza we’ve had. Reminded us of home. Good amount of cheese and toppings. Service was perfect. Will definitely be back on our next visit. A medium is definitely good for 3-4 to share.
08.2021Nathaniel
OMG!!! THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!! Ok let me breath. ☺️, on my lunch break my coworker and I picked this place at random. I’m soooooo glad we did. I ordered the Calamari and the Philly Grinder with the SOTD. It didn’t take long and the small time we waited was worth it. Everything is so fresh. The one waitress was quick, accurate and friendly. Lastly the price was reasonable and worth every penny. Simply put, do yourself a favor and stop by here. NOW!!
08.2021Gloria
Stopped here during our visit. Ordered the “brothers pizza” with two dinner sized salads. The house greek dressed is SO DELICIOUS!!! And the pizza was the most comforting pizza we’ve had. Reminded us of home. Good amount of cheese and toppings. Service was perfect. Will definitely be back on our next visit. A medium is definitely good for 3-4 to share.
08.2021Nathaniel
OMG!!! THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!! Ok let me breath. ☺️, on my lunch break my coworker and I picked this place at random. I’m soooooo glad we did. I ordered the Calamari and the Philly Grinder with the SOTD. It didn’t take long and the small time we waited was worth it. Everything is so fresh. The one waitress was quick, accurate and friendly. Lastly the price was reasonable and worth every penny. Simply put, do yourself a favor and stop by here. NOW!!
08.2021Jaime
I remember coming to this restaurant in my late teens. They have been in business for over forty years and have three locations.. The pizza here is excellent. They offer hot and cold sandwiches/heroes, soups , platters and salads. They make their own salad dressing and bottle and sell it in their restaurants. Prices are average and service is friendly. All three locations have always been extremely clean.
08.2019Daniel
This makes the eight branch of Four Brothers reviewed. Quality food at fair prices. Friendly local waitstaff. Clean facilities with nice ambience. Intriguing frescos depicting scenes from ancient Greek literature/mythology. Free wi-fi and ample parking out front. The only issue this visit was that the tuna melt's bread was so dry as to be flaking all over the place. Otherwise the food was delicious.
08.2019Jaime
I remember coming to this restaurant in my late teens. They have been in business for over forty years and have three locations.. The pizza here is excellent. They offer hot and cold sandwiches/heroes, soups , platters and salads. They make their own salad dressing and bottle and sell it in their restaurants. Prices are average and service is friendly. All three locations have always been extremely clean.
08.2019Daniel
This makes the eight branch of Four Brothers reviewed. Quality food at fair prices. Friendly local waitstaff. Clean facilities with nice ambience. Intriguing frescos depicting scenes from ancient Greek literature/mythology. Free wi-fi and ample parking out front. The only issue this visit was that the tuna melt's bread was so dry as to be flaking all over the place. Otherwise the food was delicious.
08.2019Jaime
I remember coming to this restaurant in my late teens. They have been in business for over forty years and have three locations.. The pizza here is excellent. They offer hot and cold sandwiches/heroes, soups , platters and salads. They make their own salad dressing and bottle and sell it in their restaurants. Prices are average and service is friendly. All three locations have always been extremely clean.
08.2019Daniel
This makes the eight branch of Four Brothers reviewed. Quality food at fair prices. Friendly local waitstaff. Clean facilities with nice ambience. Intriguing frescos depicting scenes from ancient Greek literature/mythology. Free wi-fi and ample parking out front. The only issue this visit was that the tuna melt's bread was so dry as to be flaking all over the place. Otherwise the food was delicious.
08.2019