Best bagel shop in Caldwell, New Jersey (NJ) 2025

Second time in two weeks that I was overcharged. Ordered only one item: an extra large coffee, and was charged for a donut as well. The first time I chalked it up to a mistake, but when it happened a second time only 2 weeks later, I have a hard time believing this is accidental. Both times when I brought it to their attention after swiping my card and seeing the extra $1.50 charge, cashier was rude and unapologetic and made it seem like I was at fault for holding up the line. Rather than give me back the difference, she said I’ll give you a donut next time. I said no thank you, I don’t want a donut, I’d like the amount I was overcharged to be returned. She seemed irritated and annoyed. As convenient as this location is for me, as a matter of principle I will not be returning. Customers beware. ~Aylin

coffee shop bagel shop bakery breakfast restaurant donut shop fast food restaurant meal takeaway