Best bagel shop in Bohemia, New York (NY) 2025

Hands down the best catering experience I ever had!! It was a last minute party my family asked me to host since cousins from out West unexpectedly visited ( that’s another story ). This was on a Friday and we were looking to throw a party on Saturday afternoon. I called The Gourmet Bagel Co and explained my situation. The owners were fantastic and extremely accommodating given the short notice. They went through the menu and made suggestions for the amount of people I had. The next day they delivered amazing platters of wraps, salads and mini sandwiches that my family loved. The food was simply amazing! They use really good ingredients and didn’t cut any corners on the presentation. My wife was thrilled and insists we only cater from them in the future. Thanks for helping on such short notice and delivering an amazing meal for an unexpected event ~Michael

Went on a Sunday morning at 8am and they were out of heroes for the hungry man so they made on a roll. It was okay. They also did not have the cookies on their menu. The bagels were good ~Jay