Best american restaurant in East Islip, New York (NY) 2024

Absolutely amazing experience! Jamie was an attentive and knowledgeable server. My sister and brother in law both came in for the lobster rolls which were super yummy and full of lobster. My sister in law also enjoyed a nice bowl of lobster bisque. My husband and I split the mussels scampi (probably the best mussels I have ever had), fried calamari which was perfectly cooked and crispy just the way we like it and steak tidbits which were by far some of the best we have had. Definitely worth checking out! We can not wait to come back! Keep up the good work Chef Michael 😋 ~Denise

My parents discovered this little gem when visiting me from NJ, and we absolutely love it! The blueberry pancakes(short stack) are always our choice for breakfast, and you definitely don't want to finish dinner without a slice of pie(apple is one of our favorites). I love the meatloaf, too. The service has always been great when I have dined there, and I am so glad they are also on Door Dash so that I can continue to support them throughout the pandemic. I am thrilled to be a returning, happy customer, and I would definitely recommend this place to anyone! ~Laura