Best convenience store in Farmingdale, New York (NY) 2025

We are from out of town and puppysitting for our son. My husband forgot an important med at home. The pharmacist Matt went above and beyond to help me out with the RX. He stayed on the phone and tried several different ways to run the script for different discounts since it was not covered by my insurance. Thank you very much. ~Donna

Filled up with 91 octane today from less than 1/4 tank, car immediately stalls (this is an obvious symptom of water in the gas). I went inside and asked the owner for a free water removal treatment ($8.99 bottle) as there’s water in their gas and I was given the runaround. I left and went to another station down the road and bought one (my car stalled 5 more times on the way but I wasn’t giving this place another penny). Luckily that did the trick since there was obviously water in their gas. My family and I will avoid this Sunoco (and others) moving forward ~scott

I love this gas station and since I live so close I go here allllllll the time!! They are friendly and very helpful, I could go as far as to say they have perfect customer service. But there are three different guys that work at this station that I have dealt with, and the one guy that is really really old has no idea how to work the computer system, he is 100% rude, and completely unhelpful no matter what you ask him to do. Even picking out a pack of cigarettes is an issue for this old man. If you happen to go there when he is behind the counter, I wish you luck because he is the absolute worst, or just go a like a block further down 109 and go to the 7-11 instead. ~Chrissy

Rude staff, can barely communicate. Refuses to refund non-working item, incredibly rude and dismissive. I call after confronting manager, and the man working front end pretends like he doesn’t understand what i was saying, then claims “it wasn’t this store”, (i patronize this business on my way to work, i think I’d know the address.) He then hangs up the phone. Rude staff, these individuals should never be working around people. ~Darbear