Best pizza restaurant in Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania (PA) 2025

This monstrosity of a pizza was delivered to me. I did take the only edible piece and give it to my son while I called. The girl who answered the phone was so beyond snappy and rude. She said I could return the pizza for a new one or get a gift certificate. I told her that my 2 yo was eating the piece of pizza and she said I had no choice but to take a gift certificate because he was eating the pizza. Well that doesn’t help us not having edible food for tonight for everyone else. We also have Covid so they couldn’t accept the pizza back anyways and if they would take it back that’s super concerning. My BIL called back after our phone conversation because it’s unacceptable and I’m too sick to even pick up my head and the girl was extremely rude to him as well. This is so consistent with this location. Truly awful service and it always seems like the food is gross. This is the final straw. Update: they did send a replacement pizza after talking in circles. ~Megan