Best pizza restaurant in Appleton, Wisconsin (WI) 2024

I was super excited to try homerun pizza only to be very disappointed. We got the pizza delivered only to have it luke warm. Crust was soggy (the bottom of the crust seemed like it wasn't cooked enough), hardly any sausage (and paid extra for their homemade Italian sausage), and didn't get the cheese pull others seem to have in reviews. I called and was told to ask for less mushrooms next time because that's what made my crust soggy (I never asked for extra mushrooms so being my first time ordering not sure how I'm supposed to know that) ended up getting a gift card for part of what I paid for the pizza. ~Samantha