Best toy store in New Berlin, Wisconsin (WI) 2025

Had a similar experience selling as some others have mentioned in their reviews. I had come to the store for the first time, and while I did not even bother to look through what items they were willing to buy and which ones they had rejected, the lady ensured that she gave me the spiel about how some of the items were inexpensive enough for customers to buy new and how some of the items were not in pairs. From what I see in the reviews, it seems like they say the same thing to a lot of the sellers. I think the team here needs to be coached that sellers come to the store with the best intentions of ensuring that their baby's much loved items are not thrown away and wasted. I can say that I did not travel 50 miles back and forth to get that bad attitude! ~Priyanka

consignment shop baby clothing store childrens book store childrens clothing store clothing store toy store youth clothing store

This is a brand new Dollar Tree in the home of a former Ace Hardware. I went midweek, a few days after the "Grand Opening" banner went up over Labor Day weekend. We also went early in the morning to avoid crowds. I was disappointed to see so few people wearing masks, especially the employees. The store itself is bright and well lit, with wide aisles. Since this store is replacing the one very close by, almost across the street, it is a huge improvement over that dim, cramped store. We found tons of art and craft supplies that we didn't know we needed, as well as lots of other fun stuff. Oddly there was no "anti-itch" cream that I was looking for after being bit up by mosquitoes lately. However, they haven't quite unpacked all the inventory yet, as evidenced by the boxes around and a couple of gaps in the shelves. My daughter was thrilled they had two types of "blind bag" items, one with plastic animals, one with lip gloss, and I liked the official Barbie accessories, like shoes or purses, for $1. I am impressed by the big freezer section, but didn't try anything there yet. We did buy a "Stroopwafel" (caramel wafer cookie) from the Netherlands that was delicious though! ~Space

dollar store craft store discount store grocery store home goods store kitchen supply store party store school supply store toy store variety store