bakery
Closed Now
Bethel Bakery in Bethel Park (5200 Brightwood Rd, PA 15102)
About:
Popular, classic bakeshop whipping up house, seasonal & custom cakes, plus other sweets, since 1955.
Bethel Bakery is located in Bethel Park (Pennsylvania state) on the street of 5200 Brightwood Rd. If you want to ask about something we recommend contacting this place by phone. The Phone number is +1412-835-6658. You can get more information from their website: https://bethelbakery.com/. The coordinates that you can use in navigation applications to get to find Bethel Bakery quickly are 40.329698, -80.030254. Scroll down to find out opening hours, reviews and other important information about Bethel Bakery.
Have you noticed incorrect information? Contact us and send us the details!
Show menuAvailable amenities
Planning
- Quick visit
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeaway
Unavailable amenities
Service options
- Delivery
- Dine-in
Karen
Ordered yums yummy today and this is what they looked like when I took them out of the bag. First off they ate usually put in a box because they have cream and icing How do you expect that to travel in a bag. Well we all see stuck to the paper
11.2022Jo
The most beautiful cake I have ever had the pleasure to share with someone I love (my wife's birthday). Bethel Bakery is always delicious and never disappoints, we use them for every occasion and it is very much a sweet tradition for our family. The forget me not style cake was prepared by Amanda and she did a tremendous job!
10.2022Martina
Bethel Bakery absolutely nailed our wedding cake design! They executed on our vision perfectly and were very detailed with their approach. The team was responsive and answered all of our questions, handled delivery and set-up and our family & friends LOVED the spice flavor we selected! They are still talking about it... Would recommend Bethel to all brides!
09.2022LAK
Some items were good, like some of the cookies, but there are other items that have no taste and are just dough and sugar. Not worth the calories or effort. I read so many excellent reviews for this place that I made a special trip to check it out. Not worth it. Pros: very friendly staff who is willing to help and explain items. Large assortment of cookies, muffins, cakes and other baked goods. Very attractive items make you want to eat them. Cons: some items lacked taste. Generally, the chocolate items were good, but anything with fruit or sprinkles are bland. Had a okay muffin, but then tasted the puffed dough with sugar and ended up throwing it out as it was not worth the calories. It's nice to see a non-grocery store bakery, but the prices are also a bit high. This is expected right now, but $28 for a round two-layer cake is ridiculous. This is for a regular cake out of the case, not a custom cake. Cookies are $0.60 to $1.25 each. Muffins $1.79 each.
09.2022Madeline
I’ve had so many delicious things from this bakery, I knew I wanted my wedding cake from there. The staff are so nice and helpful, and the prices really can’t be beat for the quality. They had great communication about my wedding cake. We got a white cake with peanut butter buttercream and chocolate fudge filling, iced with their amazing French buttercream. The decoration was beautiful, they even coordinates the floral design with the design on my wedding dress!!
08.2022J
Tried this bakery because they're supposed to have amazing buttercream. Not impressed. (Eileen's bakery in Buffalo has amazing buttercream) I don't see the hype at all, the buttercream is just like butter with a bunch of sugar in it. That's exactly what the texture and taste is like. The locks were good but nothing better than you would find in a grocery store. The cheese danish was good but nothing impressive. The French pastry and carrot cake square both were soft and moist but did not taste fresh. They both tasted like something that was sitting in a refrigerator uncovered. The brownie was ok. I've had much better from a grocery store bakery. The buttercream donuts were ok, the donut part did not seem particularly soft and fresh, it was kind of dried out. there was nothing we had at this bakery that was better than anything you would get at a grocery store. Would definitely not go back. We tried prantls bakery too and we liked the things we got from there much better, although the Northside location is in the pit of the ghetto, go to a different location.
07.2022Sam
People constantly bring their stuff to my workplace and every single thing I’ve tried from Bethel Bakery has blown me away. It seems that they don’t sell anything without mastering it first. Their frosting has the perfect consistency, the cake is JUST moist enough, for once in my life I can eat more than one piece at a time, their chocolate chip cookies taste like those expensive ones you see at the grocery store, and the peanut butter in their buckeyes left me speechless. If you’re looking for baked goods? catering for a party, or anything of the like, definitely give these guys a shot - you won’t regret it.
06.2022Kim
The cake. The cookies. Perfection. Our virtual tasting session was simple and informative. I'm actually so glad that they sent samples that I would have never chosen because their mango filling is to die for!! The team at Bethel Bakery was easy to work with and helped us design the perfect wedding cake! The only thing that could have made things easier on our end would have been recommendations on the ribbon we used on the buttercream, but we got there and our cake turned out amazing <3
06.2022Cindy
The photo below was the cake we had at my daughter's baby shower. The cake was perfect and everyone loved it. We had such a wonderful experience with your bakery. I highly recommend your bakery! Thank you very much!!!
05.2022Alex
We got 2 cakes for my daughters first birthday and they were excellent! FYI, the itty bitty cake is perfect for a 1 year old to tear in to. We also got some muffins for breakfast and those were great as well. We will definitely continue to buy cakes for special occasions from Bethel Bakery!
11.2021