Best pizza restaurant in Peoria, Arizona (AZ) 2025

Pizza and wings were cold by the time I received them. Five out of the sixteen Honey BBQ boneless wings were just breading no chicken. Pizza hut used to provide parm, red peppers, and plates with deliveries. A little cost for lots of smiles. Driver was polite and courteous. ~GT

Usually LOVE Peter Piper, we've gone to this one for years and they were consistently good. We encountered a big problem when we ordered a 2 XL pepperoni pizzas for delivery last night. We got one normal, fresh pepperoni pizza. The second pizza was unfortunately a pizza that had been a couple different pizzas that had been puzzled together to make a whole pizza. Different sizes, toppings, haphazardly fit together. What's most confusing is that 3 of the pieces were mushroom pizza, 1 of the mushroom pieces wasn't even in order next to the other two...meaning someone put them in the box, not even trying to make it look like it was legit/purposefully done (for example: if we had ordered 1/4 mushroom and 3/4 pepperoni). It just seemed careless and kinda made us uneasy like we just got delivered scraps of random pies that had been sitting out or whatever. Also my bro has a mushroom allergy, not deathly or anything, but it definitely made us feel more sensitive about a situation that already kind of rubbed us the wrong way. So to be fair, their pizza is good but maybe dine-in, if you can! ~Logan

Ordered cheese pizza w/mushrooms & olives, NO SAUCE. I don't like sauce because these pizza places load pie w/2 much sauce, & all u can taste is sauce. I hardly got any toppings for the price, & presentaition looked terrible, just thrown on. Thats why they only got 2 stars. They also can't print u a receipt, which has been going on for a bit. The owner or manager should be taking care of that, I would think. Looks like their eyes were closed when they threw on the toppings. The pizza did taste really good tho. I love their pizza crust, soo delish! I also bought their pizza seasoning which is excellent, I buy that all the time, & shake it all over my pizza, soo delish Parking: Plenty of parking, right in front of, & all around ~BERIN