Best restaurant in San Anselmo, California (CA) 2024

Disappointed by the fact that I let them know three times ahead of my reservation that we were celebrating a birthday, and even at some point discretely during the dinner, and they forgot to bring the candle, even though they had assured me on the phone that they would do so. When you travel 1.5 hours to the restaurant and save up to dine there, you would expect a little care for each customer. When we arrived at the restaurant, a woman greeted us coldly and did not even acknowledge our reservation. Aside from that element which dampened my time there, Madcap owns a great plate collection which enhances one’s dining experience significantly! Their dishes were beautifully presented, and most of them had their produces’ flavours enhanced rather than masked, which was a strong positive element. Our waiter was delightful. If not for the birthday mishap and the unfriendliness of the hostess, I surely would have recommended them more. ~Aliya

Special wine bar. Great space for a glass at the bar or sit-down dinner. The place is very warm and inviting. It offers an excellent and eclectic wine list, with quality bites to match. The owners, Vincent and Colm, are always there attending to guests in person and engaging in conversations despite it getting quite busy most nights. The events and specials are fun (e.g. oyster and prosecco special). Refreshing and cozy family run business with a fantastic wine selection. ~Dalia