Best sandwich shop in North Haven, Connecticut (CT) 2024

First time ever eating at Jersey Mike's. Ordered online, a few minutes later the order was waiting for me at the pick-up location by the ordering counter. I had the Portobello Cheese Steak sub and my wife had the Original Italian sub. Both of them were delicious! We were full and satisfied with our orders. A little pricey, but worth it. Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes … More ~Wai01

This is my go-to subway in north haven. Near where I work, off sackett point, there's 2 within range to run to on lunch break. This one on universal, and another on Washington. Even though they all use the same pre-made ingredients, their tuna always tastes better to me. So I recently started using online ordering. But I've had some issues. First, when I order my chopped salad, I came to pick it up and it wasn't chopped... twice! Another time, it didn't have all the stuff on I asked for. So I resolved to ordering sandwich a couple times after that. Last week I ordered online, when I got there they were packed. They never got to make my order. Didn't have time to even greet me at the register. So I got in line, told them I was the online order and to just refund me. The lady, Jennifer, was extremely apologetic, refunded me, gave me free soda, told me next salad is on the house. I completely understood they got busy. It's hard to make a meal for someone not in the store, when you've got a line of real people in front of you. And to be honest, I've never seen it THAT busy b4, and I think they were short staffed, so I felt for them! They're nice ladies. But for that and the other problems I had with online ordering, I can't give full stars. **had to downgrade them. Just more and more problems. I ordered online for a tuna wrap. Used my points and only had to pay like less than $3. I get to store only to find out they didn't make my order because, again, they were out of tuna. So i wound up just getting something else. Asked if they can cancel my order b/c A.) I want my money back and B.) I want my points back ...to use for THIS new order. Guy told me he can't do that in store i have to do it online! SO i pay $9 for this new order. GO back to work and can't find a direct way to cancel my order. I send an email with all info. 10 mins later my phone rings, an 877 number. I don't pick up. 10 mins after that I get an email from subway, "we tried to call you but no one answered the phone. We need more info for your request, please call us back." I've called them back 3 times since, responded to the email, and RESENT another email request. Nothing. Out of my money and out of my points. BUt that's ok because they can take the points I have and shove it. I will NEVER go to another subway again. And there's been soooo many problems I've encounted with the online ordering, I can never reccommend it to anyone. Especially if there's a mixup and you need your money back --- seems like a fair request. Give me my money back for the food that you never gave me. THIEVES. if it was more than $2 I would still pursue it, but they can keep my $2. it'll be the last money they get from me. ~Shannon