Best pizza restaurant in Huntington, Indiana (IN) 2024

Absolutely the worst customer service ever. There call center told us the wrong time, by over an hour. Hung around in town to get the pizza and when we showed up they said “sorry it’s gonna be another 45 minutes”. When I complained and asked the manager about it he just said “ we get a lot of complaints about it but it’s a major time saver for us” I asked if he was ok with losing business and he said “whatever “. They made no effort to make it right. Terrible customer service will not go back. ~Jake

I'd say this place is a solid 4.5 stars, and I'll very likely be back again. For one thing, the gentleman answering the phone and seemingly running the place all by himself on a Saturday was friendly, polite, and professional on the phone. The food was ready on-time, and the thin-crust 'The Z-pizza' is pretty good. The Chicken Club Sub is delicious though and stole all the limelight 😋 There is an extra 4% charge for using a credit card, which is mostly understandable since they probably paid 2.9% - 3.9% + $0.30, but just something to keep in mind, especially if you're comparing prices to some other pizza joint which probably doesn't do the same. The total for a 10" pizza and a 12" sub was roughly $25 before tip, and I'll probably get 3 meals out of it. Anyway, I'll be curious to check out their baked potatoes next time (though I might've been enticed earlier if the menu had pictures on it ;-) ~Tim