Best cafe in Omaha, Nebraska (NE) 2024

Pretty dissatisfied with the service here, and the portion sizes for the price. We asked for the berry preserves toppings on the side of the French toast, and were told that it was on top, or none at all. That the kitchen was to busy to be able to accommodate. That’s not a complicated or time consuming request. It’s pretty simple to simply put it into a separate bowl, or off to the side. While it was the end of the brunch rush, and they had been busy, business was definitely slowing! The French Toast, while tasty, was 3 slices of very small pieces of bread. Especially for the price! We liked the food, but definitely didn’t feel like the service and portions sizes were worth what we paid. The staff wasn’t rude, but they didn’t go out of the way to be friendly or serve well. Maybe it’s my southern roots, but to me, customer service and hospitality goes a long way. We travel frequently, and have been a lot of places. I don’t leave this review lightly. Hopefully this will help others looking to try to find a local place to try out! Tasty, but small portions for the price, and not very accommodating to customers. ~J.

Very unassuming exterior but wow! Last night I had my first experience at Sgt Peffers and it did not disappoint! We order the New Yorker (minus the anchovies because l'm a chicken) and it was everything! The toppings were so delicious and the cheese was perfection. Not to mention the amazing crust...Most definitely homemade! (Unfortunately, I did not get a photo because we were all so hungry!) If you haven't put this pizza spot on your list yet, add it! If you're visiting Omaha, and you're hungry for pizza that tastes homemade, I would highly recommend! ~Maddie