9 Best pizza restaurant in Omaha, Nebraska (NE) 2024

Horrible experience. First off they never seem to be open, and I was like OK short staff I get it, odd hours right now. When I ordered Thursday night the only good thing was my cheese sticks. My pizza dough was undercooked there was definitely not extra cheese on it that I ordered and the slices were oddly cut. It tasted horrible. ~Elizabeth

I would have gave them 5 stars but they messed up my order. But this pizza is bomb and the breadsticks perfect but I order cheese sticks. I love Pizza Hut way more than dominoes. Do get dominoes here it is nasty gave me diarrhea ~Anson

Sure, if you want clumps of dirt with a side of your mushrooms, this is your go to place. Nothing quite like taking a bite and getting a mouth full of dirt. Upon inspection, there’s a clump of dirt along with some sprinkles on the whole pizza. Definitely won’t be back. ~Jesus

One of the best Huts I've had delivered to me. They consistently come through for the past 3 years I've lived in the area. Hasn't been this good since I worked there myself. 20 min. delivery on a Friday night and food looked and tasted great. ~Calvin

I have called 3 times to talk to a manager since my post, have been left on eternal hold each time, who does business like this? They should have their franchise terminated. I have sent a letter to Dominos corporate. Missed guarantee time by 20 minutes, both pizzas were cold, cheese dip was so over cooked/burnt there was only 3 tablespoons of cheese to eat, buffalo chicken was over cooked and cold, called the store, they really didn’t care. Got a free pizza because they missed guarantee time, will never go back, don’t waste your money ordering from this store. ~Donald

Very unassuming exterior but wow! Last night I had my first experience at Sgt Peffers and it did not disappoint! We order the New Yorker (minus the anchovies because l'm a chicken) and it was everything! The toppings were so delicious and the cheese was perfection. Not to mention the amazing crust...Most definitely homemade! (Unfortunately, I did not get a photo because we were all so hungry!) If you haven't put this pizza spot on your list yet, add it! If you're visiting Omaha, and you're hungry for pizza that tastes homemade, I would highly recommend! ~Maddie

Cheese Sauce/Dip has a very odd taste to it. When I ordered my Tres Burito and gave the cheese sauce option, I didn't realize it would come coated in it. It is edible but does taste very odd. The chip don't look burnt but taste burnt, so my guess the oil that fried them in is old. I probably won't be coming back. Food : 3/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 … More ~Sarai

Very clean restaurant..the staff does a great job here and they are all super friendly they definitely made are night alot better after stopping in here for a quick bite to eat and something cold to drink ..also bathrooms were super clean .keep up the hard work pickelmans gourmet Cafe staff ..it really shows yall care !!! ~big

This is a fun and unique Omaha original. I mean, where else can you get fries ON your pizza? And the whole concept of a restaurant serving pizzas and French fry baskets are their main two dishes is also cool. You can get a whole pie, or slices that are 1/4 of the pizza.. They even have a drive-thru pick up window if you call ahead and order. ~Frank