5 Best auto repair shop in Middletown, New York (NY) 2025

I have had multiple fantastic experiences with Monro Auto in Middletown. David Garcia is a natural when it comes managing and successfully tackling any car problems. He is always eager to solve any issue through his determination and incredible work ethic. The best mechanic in the 845, arguably the entire state of NY. God bless! ~Joseph

Super friendly service. We were driving south from VT to FL and discovered that our A/C didn’t work. I called when we were only 15 minutes away, and they were able to accommodate us immediately. We were back on the road within an hour. Highly recommend! ~Charlotte

went to get a 3 inch section of flex pipe replaced after another shop broke it replacing a section of the exhaust, original shop could not weld to repair it.midas came with a price of $489 to do it, they explained why the plrice and how it was going to be done, they said the had to unbolt the front pipe as part of the job, i stated that that was not possible because the from pipe was part of the catalytic converter. the guy was gonna show me that i didn't know what i was talking about, so he puts the car back up and looks and says, your right. so they come qith a new price of $344. . the original price for the small peice of flex pipe was $148 but he dropped the price to $129.. when i stated that the price for the pipe was less then $20., the manager got onvolved and told me how wrong i was. i get that there is a merkup on parts, but 700%?. i left and went to meineke in middletown, $244 and done ~michael

Fast and friendly service. Reasonable prices. Went with a tie that had a slow leak they fixed it and didn't even charge me. That's why I recomend this place to all my friends and family ~john

Went for an annual inspection on the car. The staff was friendly and inspected my car super fast! Will definitely return next year. Overall a great experience and I would return for any of my cars needs and definitely for my inspection for next year! Thanks guys! ~Tammi