Home New York Newburgh pizza restaurant

Best pizza restaurant in Newburgh, New York (NY) 2025

In our listing you'll find the best places from the pizza restaurant category in Newburgh, New York. Some of the most popular zip codes in Newburgh, NY for pizza restaurant include 12550.
We found 2 places.

Little Caesars Pizza

It took almost 45 minutes to get my meal after I was told it would take 15 minutes. It turned out that they forgot to call me when my meal was ready. It was almost time to return to work by the time I got my meal! This was the first time I had any issues here. Generally they are prompt and the food is good. ~Lawrence

pizza restaurant

600 Broadway , Newburgh, NY 12550

J & F

The grilled chicken salad was on point. Nice size pieces of chicken along with cucumbers, tomatoes and green peppers with the lettuce. J&F does a really good job on the fried chicken salad too. 🥗 ~James

pizza restaurant pizzatakeaway

474 Broadway , Newburgh, NY 12550

FAQ pizza restaurant in Newburgh, NY

What are the zip codes in the city of Newburgh?

City Newburgh has such zip codes as: 12550.

What are the highly rated pizza restaurant in Newburgh, NY?

The best-rated places in category pizza restaurant in city Newburgh are:

Little Caesars Pizza (600 Broadway) - 3/5 stars
J & F (474 Broadway) - 4.4/5 stars