Best pizza restaurant in Mentor, Ohio (OH) 2025

In our listing you'll find the best places from the pizza restaurant category in Mentor, Ohio. Some of the most popular zip codes in Mentor, OH for pizza restaurant include 44077, 44060.
We found 2 places.

Zeppe's Pizzeria

I will never order from this place again!!!! Terrible customer service from the general manager!!! I called to complain about the chicken I received. I ordered chicken tenders and got a cluster mess of chicken. Very dissatisfaction and I will never order from them again!!!! Pictures of what it was supposed to look like and a picture of what I received. ~jennifer

pizza restaurant catering service italian restaurant pizza delivery service

9950 Johnnycake Ridge Rd , Mentor, OH 44077

Maxim's Pizza

Only recently found Maxim's even though I've lived in the area for many years. It has become one of my favorite places for pizza. I especially like their thick crispy crust and pizza sauce and usually order the deluxe. I also prefer to eat in the small eating area so I can eat it piping hot right out of the oven. I'll usually get a couple pieces of baklava for dessert. The staff is always very friendly and accomodating. ~Ken

pizza delivery service pizza restaurant pizzatakeaway

6966 Heisley Rd , Mentor, OH 44060

FAQ pizza restaurant in Mentor, OH

What are the zip codes in the city of Mentor?

City Mentor has such zip codes as: 44077, 44060.

What are the highly rated pizza restaurant in Mentor, OH?

The best-rated places in category pizza restaurant in city Mentor are:

Zeppe's Pizzeria (9950 Johnnycake Ridge Rd) - 3.8/5 stars
Maxim's Pizza (6966 Heisley Rd) - 4.2/5 stars