Best american restaurant in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (PA) 2024

On a scale of cotton candy to Brussels sprouts, Trolley Barn Eatery reminds me of a small town romance novel. This eatery feels like it's smack dab in a small town though it's located in a Pittsburgh suburb. Orders are taken at the register in the back, and a waitress will seat you (it was packed on a Sunday morning). If you order coffee, tea, or water, you will need to serve yourself from the coffee maker by the register as well as grab your napkins and utensils. There's a certain charm about the eatery, but if you're concerned about COVID, I'd recommend ordering takeout since it's a small restaurant with a loyal crowd. The meal was delicious, and looking at the photos make me want it again! ~Barbara

Best kept secret in the strip. Family run business and all hard workers. Make you feel at home and the food never disappoints. My go to is the BLT, but everything is yummy. I’ve never had a bad experience and I come often. Love you guys! ~Cydnee

We had a good time. We happened to stroll in for a drink during Oscar Bingo which was hilarious. The bartender was really knowledgeable and attentive. We got a reasonably priced beer that exceeded my expectations. The Chocolate Chip Cookie stout smells just like the name. I would definitely check this place and it's massive beer list out again. ~Daè