6 Best tire shop in Reynoldsburg, Ohio (OH) 2025

Called up T.D. on a Saturday morning as we needed some new tires pretty bad. With no appointment made, they told me I could drop it off and while they couldn’t give me a time, they assured it could be done by closing time. We went ahead and dropped it off right around 11:30-12 because the prices were very good along with the convenient location. Within an hour of dropping it off they gave me a call and told me that they were able to finish it due to a cancellation with another customer. Tyler did an excellent job of helping and answering all of our questions. Highly recommended! ~Matthew

Last July I visited this shop and they replaced my exhaust manifold. I drove the car but it never seemed to be right. It kept smelling of exhaust gasses inside the car. I stopped by an auto parts store to check on another issue and the tech said that the manifold gaskets needed repair. I checked the mileage and discovered that I had put only about 1500 miles on the car since the repair. My receipt for the repairs said the parts and service were only warrantied for 90 days. When I returned to the shop, I learned that it was under new ownership. I explained the problem and the owner said he would order the needed parts and replace them to me at NO CHARGE. I couldn't be happier! 5 STARS PLUS for the Car Doctors!! Services: Auto engine tuning, General repairs, Auto exhaust system repair ~Paul

First off, I think Tire Discounters does a nice job overall! I typically use the E Broad location as it’s closer to home. However, I don’t know that I’ll ever go anywhere but the 256 location. Larry was top notch!!! He was extremely friendly and answered every question I had. Most of all, he was upfront and honest and made my experience a great one! If you haven’t done business with Larry, you’re missing out!! Thank you for all the help!! It’s greatly appreciated!! ~Kiki

Had an urgent tire emergency and they were the only ones nearby open on a Sunday! They were able to get me in immediately. Daryll was very welcoming and reassured me (in my extremely panicked state) that he'd take a look. It was just a quick fix (my dad didn't tighten the bolts enough on the tire when he helped me plug a hole, so it was basically about to fall off by the time I got over here) and I was back on the road in no time! I will definitely be back here next time I need some car help! Thank you for your excellent service today! ~Janet

Woke up to a flat tire and these guys were on google as the closest shop to us. Lucky our tire had a screw and a slow leak so I aired it up with my compressor and drove over, called before to see if he had my tire size and time today. He said come in 35 minutes. I was in and out within an hour. Bought a used tire $48 and it was the same brand and type of tire. 10/10 highly recommend! ~john

I was very happy with the service I received at this location. Reily was the only person working the phone and recieving customers. He also went out and communicated with the mechanics. He did this seamlessly and I can tell you that it not easy to do and keep your cool. I had hit a monster pothole and he got me in that day. He took his time with me on the phone and helped me make my decision. When I got there I was surprised to see how young Riley was. This level of customer service is rare in such a young person ~Joan